Transition Culture

An Evolving Exploration into the Head, Heart and Hands of Energy Descent

Transition Culture has moved

After eight years of frenzied blogging at this site, Transition Culture has moved to its new home. Do come and join us, but feel free to also browse this now-archived site and use the shop. Thanks for all your support, comments and input so far, and see you soon.

30 Jan 2013

‘Tangoing with a giant': Naresh Giangrande reports from Brussels

(L-R) Artur Polis, Josué Dusoulierand Naresh Giangrande giving evidence at the TEN meeting.

(L-R) Arturs Polis, Josué Dusoulier and Naresh Giangrande giving evidence at the TEN meeting.

Its official, the European Economic and Social Committee (EESC) loves Transition towns. What does that mean? We don’t know. Me and a group representing a variety of Transition Initiatives across the EU (Filipa Pimentel – Transition Portalegre Portugal;  Josué Dusoulier – Transition Ath, Belgium; Pierre Bertrand – Transition Triéves; Arturs Polis – Ikskile Transition Initiative and Christiano Bottone – Transition Monteveglio, Italy) met with them recently in Brussels.

This was the culmination of a collaboration between Filipa Pimentel and Richard Adams, a UK member of the EESC. Filipa is Transition Network’s  un- lobbyist, who is re, un, or dis engaging with the various bodies of the European Union.  The TEN section (Transport and Energy – I know, I know … confusing stuff) wanted to understand how to engage citizens in energy policy.

Richard Adams was planning a visit to the Finnish nuclear long term storage facility.  This is designed to store nuclear waste, safely, for one hundred thousand years until it is no longer hazardous (sigh). The citizens of the place where they are storing the waste are apparently happy about hosting this storage because of the citizen engagement process. Richard thought there must be other examples of good citizen engagement around energy and that’s when he learned about Transition.

But how do you visit Transition? To cut a long story short, he and Filipa arranged something that has never been done before. Nineteen members of the committee each visited their local Transition Initiative (TIs) in 10 countries. Their reports are heart warming, touching, mostly very accurate and most of all inspiring. What is particularly inspiring is how the members were themselves touched and inspired, despite many of them starting from a position of scepticism.

The Transition panel with the President of the TEN section EESC

The Transition panel with the President of the TEN section EESC

We heard many stories corroborating this, and apparently you never hear stories in the EC. “I’m a convert.” declared Antonello Pezzini after his visit to Transition Monteveglio, Italy. Andaris Gobins visited Latvia’s, and the Baltic states, first TI, Ikskile Transition Initiative, and it “motivated him so much”.  He saw a small group of people achieving extraordinary things  by building community, conducting song festivals, mushroom schools, experimenting with hemp, creating a school of nature and making birch tree juice – an old Latvian recipe.

All of the reports were overwhelmingly positive and constructive. I heard reports that included; “We don’t know how to engage with civil society, they do … we have a lot to learn from them”, “Why did Transition work in Lewes and not in Brighton?”, “lots of lessons in how to conduct ourselves in meetings”, “felt like a family”, “building real community across social boundaries”, “creating local employment”, “I can now see how the crisis is leading to innovation”, “so hands on!”, “a few people can make a big difference”, “many obstacles, great potential”.

Josué Dusoulier of Ath en Transition (Belgium) giving evidence.

Josué Dusoulier of Ath en Transition (Belgium) giving evidence.

I could go on and on, but what is clear is that there is huge scope for further communication both officially and informally.  As I left there was what we believe is the EU’s first Open Space meeting convening. There are already plans a foot to continue discussions and create the possibility for citizen engagement in shaping EU energy policy. It feels too early to draw any firm conclusions, but it’s clear that as a ‘boundary organisation’ Transition can help translate EU policy, via practical projects, into something ordinary citizens can understand.

As we continue to operate as a niche actor,  outside the mainstream ‘going for economic growth’ narrative, we can continue to innovate and design and develop new ways of living and working; ways that will eventually become mainstream. In fact much of the language and concepts we originally used setting up Transition already have. (How many times have you heard the word resilience lately- think Barack Obama’s Inauguration speech.

Filipa Pimentel.

Filipa Pimentel.

As we develop and innovate questions that come up are, ‘How do we scale up the successful parts of what we do?’, and ‘How will we, ourselves who are doing Transition profit from this work? or will others?’. Engagement with mainstream bodies like the EESC might help to answer those questions. And finally thanks to all the Transition Initiatives who took part in this process.

Naresh Giangrande 23 January 2013

PS. Click here for a copy of the final report summary to this committee done by themselves. It asks many interesting questions, and although I don’t agree with everything the EESC says, they have a perspective of ownership of and responsibility to society of making the energy transition to a renewable energy and more energy efficient world a reality. So them looking at Transition and asking,  ‘Is this going to solve the problem?’ or ‘How might this scale up into a solution?’ is informative and instructive.

Comments are now closed on this site, please visit Rob Hopkins' blog at Transition Network to read new posts and take part in discussions.


30 Jan 9:17am

This is fantastic news, and a great example of how Transition is starting to show its capacity to influence central policy from the bottom-up. Great work Filipa, Richard, Naresh and all!

Here in the UK we are also meeting with the Treasury and sharing with them our ideas of how community-led economic development, as represented by the REconomy Project among others, can be part of the solution.

Feels like it’s shaping up to be an exciting year already…

30 Jan 10:34am

Wow – very, very cool. It is very encouraging that people who can influence national and international policy are waking up to the possibility of bottom up solutions.

30 Jan 12:30pm

A big attraction of Transition is its focus on positive collaboration, being open and flexible enough to engage with things we might think we would prefer not to engage with.

If we can persuade top-down to engage with bottom up, it might create space for wonderful things to happen in the middle !

Well done Naresh and all for exploring this…

Trish Knox
31 Jan 3:22am

I really appreciate this comment:
“If we can persuade top-down to engage with bottom up, it might create space for wonderful things to happen in the middle ! Is this what resilience looks like?


31 Jan 8:35am

I’m also heart warmed by this engagement but i have a kind of irrational fear when it comes to large national and international bodies;

i think the transition that needs to happen is largely physiological and cultural. I believe that we need an almost complete collapse in faith in “the calvary”, in whatever guise, and that lack of faith will trigger the complete sense of self responsibility that is needed at the personal and community level to then go ahead and make deep changes.

Ironically, post cultural shift, we’ll need every help we can get from large national and international structure. So, in part contradicting myself, it’s good to build bridges now. tricky.

31 Jan 8:59am

As someone working on environmental policy in Brussels (through NGOs mostly, but now through a research institute), I have to say that this EESC event and reaction is a positive win, but the real effort needs to focus on the European Commission, European Parliament and with the heads of government in the European Council. These are the institutions that shape policy and take the real decisions … and are the furthest away from the people. Bring TT to them!! I’m happy to help!

2 Feb 7:36pm

Perhaps one day we’ll see a Commissioner for Transition, with a cross-portfolio mandate to support Transition initiatives and to ensure that other Commissioners only deliver policies that strengthen community (small c) reilience.